16:01:09 <skaet> #startmeeting
16:01:09 <meetingology> Meeting started Fri Feb 10 16:01:09 2012 UTC.  The chair is skaet. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.ubuntu.com/meetingology.
16:01:09 <meetingology> 
16:01:09 <meetingology> Available commands: #accept #accepted #action #agree #agreed #chair #commands #endmeeting #endvote #halp #help #idea #info #link #lurk #meetingname #meetingtopic #nick #progress #rejected #replay #restrictlogs #save #startmeeting #subtopic #topic #unchair #undo #unlurk #vote #voters #votesrequired
16:01:20 <arosales> Hello
16:01:21 <arosales> o/
16:01:35 <highvoltage> howdy
16:01:45 <ogra_> yo
16:01:52 <Cimi> ciao!
16:01:55 * stgraber waves
16:02:03 <ScottK> o/
16:02:09 <apachelogger> ahoy
16:02:12 <skaet> welcome everyone.  :)   Lets get started....
16:02:19 <skaet> [TOPIC] Release general overview - skaet
16:02:19 <skaet> Please remember to .. when you're done, and o/ if you want us to pause. :)
16:02:19 <skaet> Agenda can be found:
16:02:19 <skaet> #link https://wiki.ubuntu.com/ReleaseTeam/Meeting/2012-02-10
16:02:19 <skaet> Individual team status links will be added to it from:
16:02:19 <skaet> #link https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/thread.html
16:02:21 <skaet> .
16:02:23 <skaet> Schedule is at:
16:02:25 <skaet> #link https://wiki.ubuntu.com/PrecisePangolin/ReleaseSchedule
16:02:27 <skaet> #link http://fridge.ubuntu.com/calendars/ubuntu-release-calendar/
16:02:31 <skaet> .
16:02:33 <skaet> Bugs committed to be fixed by the engineering teams can be found:
16:02:35 <skaet> #link http://reports.qa.ubuntu.com/reports/kernel-bugs/reports/rls-p-tracking-bugs.html
16:02:37 <skaet> Bugs that you would like the engineering teams to consider for fixing, should be assigned to specific teams, so they can be found.
16:02:40 <skaet> .
16:02:42 <skaet> .
16:02:44 <skaet> Upcoming Dates:
16:02:46 <skaet> - 2012/02/16 - Feature Freeze
16:02:48 <skaet> - 2012/02/16 - 10.04.4
16:02:50 <skaet> - 2012/06/23 - UserInterfaceFreeze
16:02:52 <skaet> - 2012/06/23 - BetaFreeze at 2100 UTC
16:02:54 <skaet> - 2012/02/02 - Beta 1
16:02:56 <skaet> .
16:03:00 <skaet> ***WORKITEMS:***  trend line has definitely improved overall. :D   Thank you!
16:03:02 <skaet> Very much appreciate the effort over the last few weeks, and its lovely seeing all the features roll in.  Please keep up with the workitem updates, and marking things POSTPONED if they're not going to get done this release.
16:03:06 <skaet> #link http://status.ubuntu.com/ubuntu-precise/
16:03:08 <skaet> ..
16:03:10 * skaet just noticed cut and paste didn't have Feature Freeze time.
16:03:12 <skaet> Feature Freeze is at 2100 UTC
16:03:27 <skaet> any questions before heading in to round table?
16:04:18 <skaet> [TOPIC] Hardware Certification team update - mlegris
16:04:26 <mlegris> ]link] https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000819.html
16:04:36 <mlegris> [link] https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000819.html
16:04:41 <mlegris> whoops :0
16:04:53 <mlegris> weekly testing skipped in favor of A2 testing
16:04:58 <mlegris> any questions?
16:05:26 <mlegris> seeing none
16:05:27 <mlegris> ..
16:05:32 <skaet> Thanks mlegris!   appreciate you updating the bugs still found to precise.  :)
16:05:44 <mlegris> np skaet :0
16:05:57 <skaet> [TOPIC] QA team update -  jibel
16:06:15 <jibel> #link https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000817.html
16:06:31 <jibel> questions/comments ?
16:07:08 <jibel> ..
16:07:18 <seb128> (hey, sorry I'm a bit late, I mixed utc,european times)
16:07:24 <skaet> Thanks for the new report format jibel.   Looks good.  :)
16:08:26 <skaet> and thanks for adding in the 10.04.4 smoke testing results.   Will look into DVD size issue with Daviey and pitti.
16:08:33 <skaet> Thanks for flagging.
16:08:35 <skaet> ..
16:09:01 * skaet doesn't see other questions.... moving on.
16:09:13 <skaet> [TOPIC] Security team Q&A - mdeslaur
16:09:25 <jdstrand> mdeslaur is off today, so I am here
16:09:33 <jdstrand> [LINK]https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000810.html
16:09:41 <jdstrand> Work is ongoing to complete feature by feature freeze, and that is looking good.
16:09:43 <skaet> welcome jdstrand, and seb128 :)
16:09:46 <jdstrand> Not much else to report. Any questions?
16:09:48 <jdstrand> ..
16:09:51 <jdstrand> skaet: thanks!
16:10:14 <skaet> Thanks jdstrand,  no questions, nice that things are smooth for the features.  :)
16:10:19 <skaet> ..
16:10:32 <skaet> [TOPIC] Kernel team Q&A - ogasawara
16:10:39 <ogasawara> [LINK] https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000809.html
16:10:39 <ogasawara> I was planning to upload 3.2.0-15.24 by end of day today, but now having
16:10:39 <ogasawara> seen the planned gcc-4.6 update over the weekend I might wait to
16:10:39 <ogasawara> upload on Monday.  This upload will contain a few fixes for CVE's,
16:10:39 <ogasawara> resolve some external monitor issues wwith arrandale, and remove some
16:10:39 <ogasawara> harmlessi, yet ominous, warning messages for xHCI.
16:10:47 <ogasawara> Questions?
16:10:47 <ogasawara> ..
16:11:15 <skaet> Thanks ogasawara,  was going to ask if the gcc-4.6 upload was impacting you,  but you've answered.  :)
16:11:38 <ogasawara> skaet: there's nothing critical that has to get out, so we can wait to upload
16:11:53 * skaet nods
16:12:27 <skaet> I haven't seen anyone else comment on it,  on the list either,  so hopefully no one else impacted.
16:13:00 <skaet> [TOPIC] Foundations team Q&A - stgraber
16:13:20 <stgraber> https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000813.html
16:13:35 <stgraber> questions?
16:13:36 <stgraber> ..
16:14:04 <skaet> Thanks stgraber!   Any feature freeze exceptions being contemplated?
16:14:08 <skaet> ..
16:14:29 <stgraber> not that I'm aware of
16:14:37 * skaet likes that answer.  :)
16:14:43 <skaet> thanks.
16:15:16 <skaet> [TOPIC] Server team Q&A - arosales
16:15:32 <arosales> Updated link
16:15:39 <arosales> #link https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000828.html
16:15:45 <arosales> Work continues on OpenStack, and Juju-Jitsu landed to help with tool integration with Juju.
16:15:56 <arosales> Also, OpenMPI packaging work is in danger of not making feature freeze. Major impact to anyone?
16:16:07 <arosales> mainly affecting ARM
16:16:18 <skaet> ogra_, ^ ?
16:16:47 <ogra_> skaet, yes ?
16:16:56 <arosales> #linkd https://blueprints.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+spec/servercloud-p-arm-openmpi
16:17:10 * ogra_ wonders what he is supposed to say, we will adapt to any arising probs as usual :)
16:17:46 <skaet> thanks ogra_ just wanted to make sure you had a chance to pipe up.  :)
16:17:49 <arosales> orga Do you know if OpenMPI is a critical package need?
16:18:21 <ogra_> arosales, no, sorry, NCommander leads the server stuff, i dont have many infos
16:18:26 <skaet> arosales,  how soon after FF is it likely to land?
16:18:41 <NCommander> arosales: openmpi isconsidered extremely important
16:18:48 <arosales> ogra_: ok, thanks. I'll be sure to touch base with NCommander and team.
16:18:49 <ogra_> ah, there he is :)
16:18:59 <arosales> ah  . . .
16:19:21 <arosales> NCommander: I'll talk to you more offline, thanks for the update.
16:19:35 <arosales> thats all I had for server, any questions/comments?
16:19:38 <arosales> ...
16:19:44 <skaet> Thanks arosales! :)
16:19:59 <skaet> [TOPIC] ARM team Q&A - ogra_
16:20:04 <ogra_> hi !
16:20:07 <ogra_> https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000820.html
16:20:38 <ogra_> there might additionally be some qemu changes that i didnt list (and sorry for the wrong date) ... they will only impact arm though
16:20:41 <ogra_> ..
16:20:48 <skaet> Thanks ogra_!
16:21:05 <skaet> what's the status on armel vs. armhf?   we disabling armel soon?
16:21:17 <ogra_> ask again next thu. :)
16:21:26 <ogra_> but yeah, looks like it will be armhf
16:21:27 <skaet> lol,  will do.
16:21:31 <ogra_> ..
16:21:31 <skaet> :)
16:22:01 <skaet> any FF exceptions on the horizon?
16:22:09 <ogra_> not that i know of atm
16:22:17 <ogra_> but that doesnt mean much :P
16:22:17 <skaet> okie.   thanks!
16:22:19 <ogra_> ..
16:22:50 <skaet> [TOPIC] Linaro team Q&A - fabo
16:24:09 <skaet> hmm... will move on.
16:24:28 <skaet> [TOPIC] Desktop Team Q&A - seb128
16:24:39 <seb128> [LINK] https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000824.html
16:24:48 <seb128> New compiz will be uploaded RSN (Didier has a first version being tested in his ppa)
16:24:56 <seb128> There is also a new unity planned for next week
16:25:06 <seb128> otherwise we are mostly on track to land features on time
16:25:08 <seb128> questions?
16:25:08 <seb128> ..
16:25:28 <seb128> RSN == monday most likely (if w.e ppa testing is good)
16:25:35 <skaet> Thanks seb128!
16:26:01 * skaet likes earlier in the week the better.  :)
16:27:05 <skaet> [TOPIC] Unity Framework Team Q&A - dbarth
16:27:09 <dbarth> hi
16:27:12 <skaet> :)
16:27:13 <dbarth> status report at: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/DesktopExperienceTeam/ReleaseStatus
16:27:25 <dbarth> ie, what seb128 just said
16:27:26 <dbarth> +
16:27:31 <dbarth> the HUD is landed
16:27:40 <dbarth> and the integrated menu mode is in 3D as well
16:27:53 <dbarth> but not 2D, we'll need an FFE for it most probably
16:28:10 <seb128> dbarth, the compiz and indicator-appmenu parts for integrated menu landed? where?
16:28:16 <dbarth> this is a "big" bug fix, looking more like a last feature in fact
16:28:23 <seb128> dbarth, the compiz version for monday doesn't have them...
16:28:50 <Cimi> indeed, afaics unity doesn't have them too now
16:28:52 <Cimi> next week?
16:28:58 <dbarth> well, i'm told it's in 3d at least, but then the FFE may be bigger :/
16:29:24 <skaet> How soon after FF is the 2D likely to land (ie. before Beta 1 or not?)
16:29:25 <dbarth> ..
16:29:32 <skaet> Thanks dbarth.  :)
16:29:36 <dbarth> 2D was close to having it, ie for Thursday
16:29:47 <dbarth> but we'd rather freeze earliy and deliver something solid
16:30:13 <skaet> Thanks.  Appreciate the solid.   :)
16:30:16 <seb128> didrocks says that the local menu should be integrated in compiz after the monday release
16:30:34 <seb128> so I guess that's going to be a second compiz following up after the monday one
16:31:03 <Cimi> makes sense
16:31:13 <skaet> Thanks seb128, dbarth - that seems reasonable.
16:31:55 <skaet> [TOPIC] Unity Services and Settings Team  Q&A - Cimi
16:32:01 <Cimi> #link https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000823.html
16:32:41 <Cimi> I think it's mostly in the mail, general work in stabilizing and bugfixing indicators
16:32:52 <Cimi> work on indicator printers
16:33:05 <Cimi> improvements on the touch support
16:33:09 <Cimi> any question?
16:33:10 <Cimi> ..
16:33:35 <skaet> Thanks Cimi!   Any FF exceptions being contemplated?
16:33:59 <Cimi> skaet, not at the moment
16:34:23 <Cimi> of course let's see local integrated menus and HUD
16:34:28 <Cimi> when they will land
16:35:32 <Cimi> all fine? cool
16:35:54 <skaet> will follow up a bit more offline then.  :)
16:36:05 <Cimi> ahah :)
16:36:45 <skaet> [TOPIC] Kubuntu Team Q&A - ScottK or apachelogger
16:36:59 <apachelogger> haven't done anything much useful.... still to be done before FF: telepathy (mostly finished), rekonq (pending packaging), owncloud, oxygen-gtk3 (waiting on a way to set GTK3 theme from KDE envrionment without messing up the setting for gtk using envrionments, which turns out to be a major pain as GTK3 failed to consider xdesktop setups entirely)
16:37:10 <apachelogger> questions?
16:37:27 <skaet> Thanks apachelogger!   Any FFE's looking necessary?
16:38:00 <apachelogger> not at this point, unless the GTK3 stuff gets further delayed
16:38:42 <skaet> ok,  thanks.  :)
16:39:09 <skaet> [TOPIC] Edubuntu Team Q&A - stgraber or highvoltage
16:39:19 <stgraber> https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000812.html
16:39:24 <stgraber> highvoltage: anything I forgot? ^
16:40:16 <stgraber> ..
16:40:23 <stgraber> oh, questions?
16:40:24 <stgraber> ..
16:40:35 <skaet> Thanks stgraber!  :)
16:40:57 <skaet> same question for you here,  any FFE's on the horizon?
16:41:09 <stgraber> nope
16:41:14 <skaet> coolio.  :)
16:41:45 <skaet> [TOPIC] Xubuntu Team Q&A - madnick
16:42:56 * skaet looks around for someone else from Xubuntu if madnick's not around?
16:44:02 <skaet> hmm... not seeking ScottL/scott-work in the channel today either,  skipping Ubuntu-Studio too.
16:44:16 <skaet> [TOPIC] Lubuntu Team Q&A - gilir
16:44:21 <gilir> hi :)
16:44:28 <skaet> :)
16:44:29 <gilir> https://lists.ubuntu.com/archives/ubuntu-release/2012-February/000818.html
16:44:38 <gilir> just to add that alternate installation is actually working
16:44:45 <gilir> still testing but I'm sure it's a mess in lubuntu seed
16:44:48 <gilir> ..
16:45:15 <skaet> Thanks gilir!   good to hear its working now.
16:45:39 <skaet> any FFE's looking likely?  or are you all set now for the release?
16:46:03 <gilir> I should be able to upload all packages before FF
16:46:12 <skaet> great.  :)
16:46:39 <skaet> [TOPIC] MOTU Team Q&A - tumbleweed or Laney
16:47:32 <skaet> or ScottK?
16:47:53 <ScottK> Dunno.  I haven't been following things very closely this week.
16:47:58 <Laney> Err, I wasn't prepared for this
16:48:10 <Laney> But (a) I am considering a GHC transition along with iulian
16:48:24 <Laney> (b) I recently got concerned about uninstallable packages so will be calling for help in fixing those sooni
16:48:55 <Laney> ..
16:49:39 <skaet> Thanks for the update Laney.  Yeah, I was also noticing we still have a few FTBFS...  be nice to get them cleaned up before the release, indeed.
16:50:01 <Laney> that too
16:50:13 * Laney is off to Wales now, tara
16:50:22 <skaet> [TOPIC] 10.04.4
16:51:15 <skaet> Just a reminder we'll also be releasing 10.04.4 next week,  as well as feature freeze going on.    Daviey will be coordinating getting the images polished if you have questions.
16:51:32 <skaet> (and I'll be involved too.... ;) )
16:51:35 <skaet> ..
16:51:46 <skaet> [TOPIC] Any other business, comments,  questions?
16:52:09 * MrChrisDruif just wants to thank everyone for their hard work
16:52:17 <MrChrisDruif> Good work team!
16:53:06 <skaet> Thanks MrChrisDruif.  :)   and I very much agree.  :D
16:53:28 * skaet looks around not seeing any o/...s
16:53:49 <skaet> Thanks mlegris, jibel, jdstrand, ogaswara, stgraber, arosales, ogra_, NCommander, seb128, dbarth, Cimi, apachelogger, gilir, Laney, ScottK
16:53:53 <skaet> #endmeeting